Murder rate in Finland, Japan higher than in US

The murder rate in Finland and Japan is higher than in the US if suicide is considered as a type of murder. In the figure below, I’ve plotted total murder rates (homicide plus suicide) for several developed-world countries. The homicide component is in blue, with the suicide rate above it, in green. In terms of this total, the US is seen to be about average among the developed counties. Mexico has the highest homicide rate for those shown, Japan has the highest suicide rate, and Russia has this highest total murder rate shown (homicide + suicide): nearly double that of the US and Canada. In Russia and Japan, some .02% of the population commit suicide every year. The Scandinavian countries are quite similar to the US, and Japan, and Mexico are far worse. Italy, Greece and the UK are better than the US, both in terms of low suicide rate and low homicide rate.

  Combined homicide and suicide rates for selected countries, 2005.


Homicide and suicide rates for selected countries, 2005 Source: Wikipedia.

In the US, pundants like Piers Morgan like to use our high murder rate as an indicator of the ills of American society: loose gun laws are to blame, they say, along with the lack of social welfare safety net, a lack of support for the arts, and a lack of education and civility in general. Japan, Canada, and Scandinavia are presented as near idyls, in these regards. When murder is considered to include suicide though, the murder-rate difference disappears. Add to this, that violent crime rates are higher in Europe, Canada, and the UK, suggesting that clean streets and education do not deter crime.

The interesting thing though is suicide, and what it suggests about happiness. According to my graphic, the happiest, safest countries appear to be Italy and Greece. Part of this is likely weather , people commit suicide more in cold countries, but another part may be that some people (malcontents?) are better served by dirty, noisy cafés and pubs where people meet and complain, and are not so well served by clean streets and civility. It’s bad enough to be a depressed outsider, but it’s really miserable if everything around you is clean, and everyone is polite but busy.

Yet another thought about the lower suicide rates in the US and Mexico, is that some of the homicide in these countries is really suicide by proxy. In the US and Mexico depressed people (particularly men) can go off to war or join gangs. They still die, but they die more heroically (they think) by homicide. They volunteer for dangerous army missions or to attack a rival drug-lord outside a bar. Either they succeed in killing someone else, or they’re shot dead. If you’re really suicidal and can’t join the army, you could move to Detroit; the average house sold for $7100 last year (it’s higher now, I think), and the homicide rate was over 56 per 100,000. As bad as that sounds, it’s half the murder rate of Greenland, assuming you take suicide to be murder.

R.E. Buxbaum, Sept 14, 2013

6 thoughts on “Murder rate in Finland, Japan higher than in US

  1. Pingback: Canada’s doctor-assisted suicide killed 10,064 in 2021 | REB Research Blog

  2. Pingback: White folks and Indians commit suicide; black folks don’t. | REB Research Blog

  3. Blue

    To take someone else’s life compared to the passive taking of your own are very different. This compilation of statistics makes no sense since one act needs violence and the other does not. Maybe the question should be where the most violence exists in a country.

    Reply
    1. R.E. Buxbaum Post author

      It’s not always unjustified to take someone else’s life, e.g. when the DC police “took down” a fellow who was trying to kill senators and congressmen. For all I know, the shooter had a death wish too, and was committing suicide by police proxy.

      Reply
  4. Royster Howell

    Well, if your going to include suicide as part of the statistic, then why not the thousands of people who needlessly die from the lax environmental and workplace laws, etc., in the USA; or from Monsanto’s frankenfoods, etc. You see the slippery slop here?

    Reply
    1. canofsand

      > the thousands of people who needlessly die from the lax environmental and workplace laws, etc., in the USA

      Perhaps because that’s utter poppycock?

      Reply

Leave a Reply